Skip navigation

Location pin icon You are viewing Modesto, CA. Not your area? Choose the location closest to you: Location pin icon We serve 2 locations! Select your service area to get started:
Location pin icon You are viewing Modesto, CA. Not your area? Choose the location closest to you: Location pin icon We serve 2 locations! Select your service area to get started:
Menu

Heating

Modesto

Repair or Replace? How to Decide What to Do with an Aging Heater in Modesto

Home | Blog | Published on January 26th, 2026

When your heater starts acting up, it can be stressful deciding the next step, especially for homeowners who rely on heating in Modesto to stay comfortable during chilly Central Valley winters. At DeHart Plumbing, Heating & Air, Inc., we’ve helped thousands of local families make smart, cost-effective decisions about their home comfort, and we’re here to help you do the same.

Start with the Age of Your Heater

Age is one of the biggest indicators of whether repair or replacement makes sense. Most furnaces and heat pumps last about 10–15 years with proper maintenance. If your system is nearing or beyond this range, repairs may only offer short-term relief. Older systems also lack the technology and efficiency of modern units, making replacement a smarter long-term investment.

Consider How Often Breakdowns Occur

An occasional repair is normal, but frequent breakdowns are a red flag. If you’re calling for service every season, those costs add up quickly—not to mention the inconvenience and discomfort of unexpected failures. When repairs become routine rather than rare, replacement often provides greater peace of mind and reliability.

Compare Repair Costs to Replacement Value

A helpful rule of thumb is to compare the cost of repairs to the value of a new system. If a single repair approaches 50% of the cost of replacement, it’s usually better to upgrade. Putting money into a failing heater can feel like throwing good money after bad. We always provide honest recommendations so you can choose the most economical path forward.

Don’t Ignore Energy Efficiency

Older heaters work harder to produce the same level of comfort, which means higher utility bills month after month. New heating systems are designed with advanced efficiency features that reduce energy use while improving indoor comfort. Upgrading can lead to noticeable monthly savings and a smaller environmental footprint, benefits that continue year after year.

Why Upgrade Before Next Winter?

Planning is key. Replacing your heater before next winter means avoiding emergency breakdowns during peak season, enjoying flexible scheduling, and taking advantage of potential rebates or financing options. You’ll also head into colder weather with confidence, knowing your home will stay warm and efficient when you need it most.

Safety and Comfort Matter

Your heater plays a critical role in home safety and comfort. Cracked heat exchangers, faulty burners, or failing electrical components can pose risks that repairs may not fully eliminate. New systems include improved safety controls, quieter operation, better airflow, and more consistent temperatures throughout your home.

For families with allergies or uneven heating issues, modern equipment can dramatically improve indoor air quality and overall comfort while reducing stress during the coldest nights. This upgrade also supports long-term reliability and adds resale appeal that buyers appreciate in today’s competitive housing market locally now.

Choosing between repair and replacement doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Our experienced team will evaluate your system, explain your options clearly, and help you make the best decision for your home and budget.

Contact DeHart Plumbing, Heating & Air, Inc. today for all your heating needs!

DeHart Plumbing, Heating, and Air Inc. Reviews

Don’t Just Take Our Word for It

Pete Herrmann's Profile Image
Google
Pete Herrmann, This week

Thank you, Dan and Dehart for your expertise in diagnosing and fine tuning our new HVAC system. Complicated case with the new technology embedded in...

Continue Reading Continue Reading

View All Reviews

DeHart Plumbing, Heating, and Air Inc. CTA Curve
DeHart Plumbing, Heating, and Air Inc. Reviews
Ready for Service? You Are The Heart of Our Business phone icon 209-523-4578